افراط‌‌‌‌گرایی فرقه‌‌‌‌ای در پاکستان و تأثیر آن بر جمهوری اسلامی ایران

نوع مقاله: مقاله پژوهشی

نویسنده

استادیار گروه علوم سیاسی دانشگاه لرستان

10.22111/jsr.2019.4674

چکیده

پاکستان از مهم‌‌ترین همسایگان شرقی ایران و از بازیگران مهم منطقه‌‌‌‌ای و اثرگذار بر ژئوپلیتیک شبه‌‌قاره است. تنوع قومی و مذهبی در این کشور و همسایگی آن با هندوستان و مناقشۀ کشمیر بر عمق استراتژیک این کشور افزوده و منجر به ایجاد حساسیت در روابط خارجی این کشور با همسایگان شرقی و غربی خود شده‌‌‌‌است. اگرچه ژئوپلیتیک موجب اهمیت پاکستان می‌‌‌‌شود، اما زمینه‌‌ساز پیدایش افراط‌‌‌‌گرایی فرقه‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌ای و بی‌‌ثباتی سیاسی در سطح ملی و منطقه‌‌‌‌ای در قبال همسایگان شده‌‌‌‌است. دراین پژوهش ریشۀ افراطی‌‌گری پاکستان در سطوح ملی و سیستمی مورد بررسی قرار می‌‌گیرد تا به این پرسش اساسی پاسخ داده‌‌شود که فرقه‌‌گرایی و افراطی‌‌گری تحت چه عواملی شکل گرفته و چه تأثیراتی بر امنیت ملی جمهوری اسلامی ایران می‌‌‌‌گذارد؟ در پاسخ به پرسش، این فرضیه مطرح می‌‌‌‌شود که افراط‌‌‌‌گرایی فرقه‌‌‌‌ای در پاکستان به‌‌‌‌دلیل تنوع و بسترهای پیچیدۀ داخلی و تحریک و تشویق قدرت‌‌های مداخله‌‌گر منجر به ایجاد تهدیدات امنیتی برای جمهوری اسلامی ایران می‌‌‌‌شود. روش تحقیق پژوهش حاضر تحلیلی-تبیینی و شیوۀ گردآوری اطلاعات، استفاده از اسناد و متون کتابخانه‌‌‌‌ای است.

کلیدواژه‌ها


عنوان مقاله [English]

Sectarian extremism in Pakistan and its impact on the Islamic Republic of Iran

نویسنده [English]

  • mehdi zolfghari
Assistant Professor of Political Science Department of Lorestan University
چکیده [English]

Extensive Abstract :
 
1-       Introduction
 
According to many scholars religion can be considered as the point of origin of many social capacities; however, if environmental requirements are not understood correctly, the same can turn into an agent in creating social divisions and finally political conflicts and internal chaos (Copeland, 2016: 5). The feeling of insecurity as well as partial deprivation combined with ethnical-religious feelings and orientations make a suitable context for turmoil and inclination of individuals toward extremist radical movements. In sectarian extremism which is a form of organized violence, it is an obligation to form identity and embark on spreading awareness and extending sectarian organization to develop the operational scope (Mori, 2016:18). The danger which factions propose to society is the spread of organized threat towards a group or some individuals (Abdo,2015 :17-18).
Meanwhile; religious and sectarian fidelity has created a suitable ground for an outbreak of a large wave of security events in southwestern Asia. As the result of these conflicts which have put nations into opposition with one another, the possibilities for coming into national agreement and explore opportunities to maximize the values have become narrowed down (Nasrollahi,2010:198). As such; the existence of a high potential for sectarian conflicts inside the security environment of Islamic Republic of Iran is one of the most important components able to produce threats for internalization of unity and national solidarity. One of the reasons to believe so is instability in neighbor countries and interference by countries of the region with an intention of exacerbating sectarianism to achieve their goals. Amongst countries of the region Pakistan maintains a high potential for sectarianism as religious sectarianism constitutes the foundation of this country. In fact, the society of Pakistan holds an ethnic and sectarian nature with various ideas and ethnic-tribal bigotry and special religious and traditional perceptions suffering from ever-widening gaps between them (Masoudnia & ShahGhale, 2009;201). Today, Pakistan has turned into the center of gravity of sectarian extremism and home to foster fighting Salafi groups (Hill,2015:17).The said factor especially when regarding long borders between Iran and this country and settlement of Baloch minority along borders has brought about threats to the I.R of Iran. Terrorist groups split from sectarianism have become activated in Iran especially in southeastern parts of the country and conducted operations against the national security of the country. Due to the importance of this issue, the current study examines sectarianism in Pakistan, its causes, and contexts of growth and geopolitical effects it has on I.R of Iran’s national security.
2-Methodology of Research
The method of this research is descriptive-explanatory which explores the causes of extremism in Pakistan, its characteristics and its status regarding national security of Iran. Data gathering was carried out by library and document research.
3-Discussion
The social and political environment of Pakistan has special complications the main reasons of it are ethnic and trial characteristic of the social structure of this country, military interference in political affairs, foreign powers interferences and most importantly, religious conflicts along with tribal rivalries. Such environment in combination with foreign powers ‘meddling with internal issues of Pakistan has created a favorable context for the growth of sectarianism. (Masoudnia & ShahGhale,2009:194). From 1947 when Pakistan first appeared as an independent country on maps, it has suffered from a myriad of problems due to a conductive background for sectarian extremism, religious fundamentalism, and interferences and unlimited power of the military. (Gerges,2014). Consequently, in recent two decades in Pakistan fundamentalism and religious sectarianism has been raising remarkably and leading into this country turning into the heart of fundamentalism and especially sectarianism. (Masoudnia & Najafi,2011:79). Thus, Pakistan depends on various schools of jurisprudence and thought with their specially formed political organizations.  We should notice that although Pakistani religions are divided into two major Sunni religious groups of Hanafi and Shiite, neither Sunni or Shiites of this country follow a single sect (Cohen,2012). In fact, not only the society of Pakistan breaks into a multitude of major and minor political groups but each major Sunni and Shiite sects of it further divides into platitude of methods and trends. To make things even more complicated, we should bear it in mind that in case of tribal and language perspective a similar situation prevails (Masoudnia & ShahGhale,2009:202).
4-Conclusion
The country of Pakistan appeared on the political map of the world with Islam as its existential cause. Since its independence, it has tried to use Islamic thinking as an identity factor. Unfortunately, Pakistan was not successful in this regard. This country was engulfed by devastating sectarianism after its independence. Today it is notorious for being the center of fundamentalism and sectarianism. Nowadays, Pakistan is known as one of the most challenging and unstable countries in the world. For that reason, sectarianism with characteristics such as totalitarianism, austerity, bigotry, fundamentalism, separation from general society aggravates various social, cultural and economic contrasts and by dividing down various identities prevents from a general sense of identity and feeling of belonging to the national space to form. Accordingly, by disrupting the normal flow of social and political order, it provokes tensions and violence and plays a significant part in instability. A whole collection of factors are amongst contributors in sectarianism and its amplification in Pakistan, the most important ones include: how Pakistan was formed in first place, political, social and economic crises of it, its special cultural-social status, deprivation and lack of prosperity and economic development, the Kashmir dispute, invasion of Afghanistan by USSR, policies of colonial powers specially the US and support from these policies by Arab countries of Persian Gulf particularly the Saudi Arabia, victory of the Islamic Revolution of Iran, weakness of Pakistan in terms of nation building, Islamization policies followed by Zia-ul-Haq, religious schools, wide ethnic and linguistic varieties along with tribal culture, weakness of government in dealing with extremist groups and the military and ISI of country. The said factors have helped with prevailing sectarianism and worsened religious and sectarian challenges.
Concerning Iran’s neighborhood with Pakistan and imposed borders between two countries which have entailed the separation of Baloch people, sectarianism in Pakistan has proposed threats to Iran’s national security. It has led to terrorist attacks in southeastern parts of Iran and challenged the national security of it. In fact, it has increased terrorism and smuggling of goods, sectarian armed conflicts, number of the terrorist groups, suicide attacks and bombings plus hostage-taking. Meanwhile, aside from foreign countries interference which plays the main role in this regard, what has prepared the background for sectarianism and its expansion in a southeastern part of the country is unbalanced development. Therefore, the province of Sistan&Baluchestan despite its high potentials is the most deprived part of the country.
 
 
 
 
 
1-      Abdo, Geneive, Salafists and Sectarianism: Twitter and Communal Conflict in the Middle East, Center for Middle East Policy, pp1-68,Brooking: 2015.
2-       Ahmadi, Hamid and Bidollah Khani, Arash, Taliban in Pakistan: Causes, Nature and Security Challenges, Quarterly Journal of Politics,pp21-37,Tehran: Volume 42, Issue 1, spring, 2012.
3-       Ahmadipour, Zahra and Heidari Mouslou, Tahmoreth and Mir-Jalali, Akbar, Explaining the Insecurity Factors in the South-East of Iran, Journal of Social Studies,pp13-44,Tehran: Vol. 20, 2011.
4-      Akbari, Hamid Reza, How ISIS Plays its Role in Middle East Political Relations, Contemporary Political Quests,pp1-26, Tehran: No. 1, 2016.
5-      Ashraf Nazari, Ali and Shohreh Pirani, Social Identity Theory and Representation of the Identity Act of ISIS, Quarterly Journal of National Studies,pp77-98, Tehran: No. 2, 1396.
6-      Baqai, Huma, “Extremism and Fundamentalism: Linkages to Terrorism, Pakistan`s Perspective,” International Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences, pp242-249,Karachi:Vol.1, No 6,2011.
7-      Bazdar, Shahnaz, The Study & Prioritization of Effective Divergent Factors in the Relations between Iran & the Islamic Countries of the Periphery, Quarterly Journal of Political Studies of the Islamic World,pp151-177,Tehran: No. 2,  2016.
8-      Chosudovsky, Michel,’Pakistan and the Global Battle Against Terrorism’, Translated by Cheshm-andaz-e-Iran,pp121-127,Tehran: May and June, 2009.
9-      Cohen ,Stephen P, The Nation and the State of Pakistan, the Washington Quarterly,pp109-122,London: Summer2012.
10-   Cohen, Maximilian, Geopolitics of Iran Gas, Translation by Ali Amiri, Lorestan University Press, Tehran: First Edition,2016.
11-  Copeland, Thomas, “Is the new terrorism really new? An analysis of the new paradigm for terrorism”, the journal of conflict studies, vol.11, no2,winter 2001
12-  Daheshyar, Hossein, Double Pillars of Instability in Pakistan, Political-Economic Information,pp4-13,Tehran: No.240-239, 2007.
13-   Daneshvar, Ismail, Wahhabism and Insecurity in Pakistan, Payam-e-Enghelab,pp46-49,Tehran: No. 5, 2011.
14-  Dehghan, Yadollah et al.,The Effect of Social Splits on the Formation and Growth of Extremism in Syria, Journal of Strategic Research,pp111-136,Tehran: No. 20, 2017.
15-  Farmaniyan, Mehdi, The Salafi Attitudes in Today’s World, Meshkat,pp77-104,Tehran: No. 104, 2009.
16-  Gerges, Fawaz A; ISIS and the third Wave of Jihadism, Current history. December,2014.
17-  Ghanbarlu, Abdullah, Political Economy of the Natural Gas Transmission Project to Pakistan, in Strategic Relationships between Iran and Pakistan, Tehran: Strategic Studies Institute, 2011.
18-  Ghosh, Partha S(a), Kashmir Revisited: Factoring Governance, Terrorism and Pakistan, South Asian, pp2-17, Heidelberg: 2017.
19-  Ghosh, Partha S. Islamic Extremism in South Asia‟, International Journal Law, Crime and Justice formerly, International Journal of the Sociology of Law,pp35-47, Vol:36, 2017.
20-  Hafez Nia, Mohammad Reza and Kaviani, Morad, The Role of Ethnic Identity in National Solidarity (Case Study of the Balochic People), Research Journal of Isfahan University,pp15-46,Isfahan: Vol. 20, No. 1, 2006.
21-  Hafez Nia, Mohammad Reza, Punjab Geopolitical Situation in Pakistan, Tehran, Al-Mahdi Publications, 2000.
22-  Hammond, Andrew, "Saudi Arabia: Cultivating sectarian spaces", The Gulf andsectarianism, European council of foreign relations, Nov2013.
23-  Hassan Purpouyan, Reza, Farzam Saber and Esmaeil Parsaei, Spatial Capacities of Chabahar Free Zone Development: Opportunities, Problems & solutions; Political-Economic Information,pp150-165,Tehran: No. 273, 2009.
24-  Hill ,Fiona ,Terrorism, Religious Extremism, and Regional Stability, International Relations, committee on the Middle East and Central Asia,July2015.
25-  Karamzadi, Moslem, Jihadi-Takfiri Salafism and the Future of Political Stability in the Middle East, The Journal of Political Studies Islamic World,pp113-142,Tehran: No. 1, 2016.
26-  Karamzadi, Moslem, the Future of Political Stability in the Middle East, The Journal of Political Studies Islamic World,pp113-142,Tehran:2016.
27-  Karimipour, Yadollah, An Introduction to Iran and its Neighbors; Tension and Threat Resources; Jahad Daneshgahi Publication, Tehran Tarbiyat-e-Mo’alem University, 2002.
28-  Keshavarz, Heydar, The Effect of Regional Salafism on the National Security of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Quarterly of Middle Eastern Studies,pp125-154,Tehran: Vol.19, No. 2, Summer, 1391.
29-  Lindberg, Miryam ,Understanding Terrorism in the Twenty-First Century, Grupo de Estudios Estratégicos GEES, 2010.
30-  MasoudNia, Hossein and Shah Qaleh Safi Allah, Investigating the Causes of Violent Behavior of Islamic Forces in Pakistan with Emphasis on Talibanism, Political Science,pp193-218,Tehran: Vol.5, No. 1, Summer, 2009.
31-  MassoudNia, Hossein and Davood Najafi, Factors Influencing the Formation and Development of Fundamentalism in Pakistan, Quarterly Subcontinent Studies,pp83-116, Zahedan: Vol.3, No. 8, Autumn, 2011.
32-  Matlabi Junaghani, Mohsen et al., The Backgrounds of Extremism Formation in Pakistan Based on Discourse Approach, Defense Policy Magazine, pp9-32,Tehran:No. 96, 2016.
33-  Mehrara, Gholamreza, Pakistan & the So-Called Problem of Taliban, Paym-e-Enghelab,No. 45, 2011.
34-  Mirzai, Alireza, Sepah-e-Sahaba and Jahangui,Army, the Representatives of Salafi-radical Extremist Thoughts, Wahhabi Critique,pp171-202,Tehran: Vol.3, No. 11, Autumn, 2013.
35-  Mollazehi, Pir Mohammad, Political and Ideological Challenges in Pakistan, Diplomatic Hamshahri,pp20-27,Tehran: No. 22, 2007.
36-  Mori,  Sebastiano & Leonardo Taccetti , Rising Extremism in Central Asia? Stability in the Heartland for a Secure Eurasia, European Institute for Asian Studies, 2016.
37-  Nasr, ValiReza, Army, Islamism and Democracy in Pakistan, Translated by: Massoum Entezam, Political Economic Information,pp22-37,Tehran: No. 238-237, 2007.
38-  Nasrallahi, Fereshte, Religion, Sectarianism and Conflict in Southwest Asia, Journal of Political Studies,pp189-205,Tehran: No. 10, winter, 2010.
39-  PishgahiFard, Zahra and Fatemeh Sadat Mirahmadi and Bahador Gholami, An Analysis of the Roots and Intensive Factors of Sectarian Conflicts in Pakistan, University of Tehran, Vice-presidency of Research, Faculty of Geography, 2012.
40-  PishgahiFard, Zahra and Mirzadeh Kouhshahi, Mehdi, Explaining the Barriers to Optimal Management of the Boundaries of the Islamic Republic of Iran and Pakistan, Quarterly of Defense Strategy,pp107-141,Tehran: Vol.9, Winter, 2011.
41-  Rafique ,Muhammad, Evolutionary Transformation of Religious Extremism and Terrorism: An Analysis of Fata-Pakistan, Institute for Strategic Studies, Research and Analysis (ISSRA),pp119-136, Islamabad: 2014.
42-  Shafiei, Nozar and Gholamreza Ghilich Khan, Explaining the Impact of Islamic Radicalism on Iran-Pakistan Relationships, Journal of Strategic Studies of the Islamic World,pp127-158,Tehran: Vol.11, No. 42, Summer, 2010.
43-  Shafiei, Nozar, Origins and Consequences of Conflict of Religious Forces with the Government of Pakistan, Diplomatic Hamshahri,pp20-27,Tehran: No. 16, 2007.
44-  Shafiei, Nozar, Pakistan's Position in the Growth of Islamism, Diplomatic Hamshahri,pp20-27,Tehran: No. 61, 2005.
45-   Zolfaghari, Mahdi and Abuzar Omrani, Effect of ISIS's Emergence on the National Security of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Islamic World Political Research Quarterly,pp169-195, Tehran: No. 2, 2017.
 
 

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Pakistan
  • Security
  • Sectarian Extremism
  • Iran
  • America